Beautiful design, which is why I chose it over the other in my cart. However I do not trust the clasp to hold my charms. I put one of the two charms (both small/dainty) on the clasp, then shook it gently while letting the charm dangle, and the charm fell off.
I messaged the seller prior to purchasing about the closing mechanism letting them know the charms contain my grandparents ashes and its ability to “click” shut is important. The seller was confident in its ability to hold my charms. Sad to say it is not as sturdy as I had hoped it would be. That being said, I will be waiting to wear and having a jeweler solder shut. Again beautiful, just sad I have to take it to a jeweler.